Buy Gold & Silver In Columbus, Ohio

The owners of this website may be paid to recommend Goldco or other companies. The content on this website, including any positive reviews of Goldco and other reviews, may not be neutral or independent. Read our Advertising Disclaimer.

Columbus, Ohio, is the state’s capital and largest city. Apart from being a hub for education, the city has become a hub for startups and entrepreneurs in recent years. This has also translated well into precious metal dealers.

Once you check out the array of dealers I have listed in this article, I am sure you can easily buy gold and silver in Columbus. You should be aware of their reputation and services, which are integral to your needs as a client.

The last thing you need is to get scammed by a shady dealer. Always ensure you visit the best facility possible and avoid any establishment you feel is not 100% forthcoming.

Important Notice! Before you continue onwards:

Sutter Gold Mining prides itself on providing the most accurate and up-to-date information possible.

I put in long, hard hours to ensure all the information I provide is reliable and helpful for you to buy gold and silver. This is simply because financial decisions like this should be well-planned!

>> CLICK HERE to read my list of the Best Gold IRA Companies. <<

Alternatively, if you want to look directly at my No.1 recommended company, click the link below. That way, you can also get a complementary precious metals investment kit for free!

Whether you are an experienced dealer or a first-time investor, there is a lot to be learned in investing in gold and silver by reading this article. This is why I recommend reading till the end!

Where To Purchase Gold & Silver In Columbus, OH

I have listed a handful of dedicated precious metal dealers you should check out in this section.

I will be talking about the various services they provide and how the community perceives them. This is how you should generally gauge how to choose a precious metal dealer.

1. American Coin & Collectibles

American Coin & Collectibles is a family-owned business established in 1978.

It was renamed American Coin in 1994 and is easily one of the oldest coin dealers in Columbus. The staff has remained the same since the beginning of the shop.

You can trust this establishment since it has an A+ rating with the Better Business Bureau. Paul L. is General Manager/Numismatist of the business and has been so for 38 years.

Moreover, he purchased many estates and liquidated millions of dollars in rare coins and precious metals during this time.

The store is also a contact for the United States Mint and a member dealer for Numismatic Guaranty Corporation.

With all these connections, the establishment offers customers expert grading and free verbal grading.

Phone Number: (614) 231-1008
Address: 3501 E Livingston Ave, Columbus, OH 43227

2. Buckeye Gold Coin & Jewelry

This one is not your average pawn shop. This business offers expert buying and selling services for gold, silver, and coins.

With years of experience in the field, they are passionate about what they do and pride themselves on their high BBB rating and excellent customer reviews.

It is with this passion that the employees take the time to explain their process and provide XRF X-ray machines. This allows customers to quickly and easily determine the composition of their items.

Being a pawn shop, they buy and sell various precious items, including gold, silver, and coins. Being a well-established business, they buy US and foreign gold coins, and gold bullion.

If you are looking for even more precious metals, they also offer their services in platinum.

Additionally, they claim to purchase the most US-minted collectible and certified coins in the city; these products are all acquired from PCGS, NGC, and other world-certified coin organizations.

Buckeye Gold Coin & Jewelry offers its services to the city of Columbus and various other areas. This can be great if you plan on ordering from outside the city.

If you are in Columbus, you can walk into any of their stores with their items without an appointment.

Phone Number: (614) 793-4653
Address: 190 Graceland Blvd, Columbus, Ohio 43214

3. Gemco Coins, Jewelry and Pawn

If you want to sell your precious metals to a PCGS Authorized Dealer, look no further than Gemco Coins, Jewelry and Pawn.

This establishment has bought and sold gold coins, silver bullion, collectible coins, and jewelry in Central Ohio since 1988.

The shop offers a wide range of services, such as providing coin-collecting supplies. They even sell manuals on how to grade gold which can be helpful for those looking to do it themselves.

Their showroom features collectible coins, gold coins, silver bullion, and other collectible items. Gemco Coins, Jewelry and Pawn is a Top Rated Plus seller on eBay.

This is perfect if you just want to order their precious metals without leaving the comfort of your home.

With over 15,000 transactions and thousands of satisfied customers throughout the United States, you know they are trustworthy.

The staff has over 60 years of combined numismatic experience and provides written insurance and estate appraisals.

Phone Number: (614) 878-2646
Address: 5311 W. Broad St, Columbus, OH 43228

4. Appraisal Services

Appraisal Services is a business that specializes in coin appraisals, grading, valuation, and liquidation.

Being an accredited business by the Better Business Bureau, and have been in business for 15 years.

The main attributes that the business is known for are its high level of customer service and overwhelmingly positive reviews.

This is from customers who have appreciated their honest and detailed appraisals. The company offers various services, including buying single coins or entire collections.

This is paired with free grading and valuation by date, mintage, and condition. This will lead you to properly understand your selling or purchasing product.

They also provide authentication services to determine if coins are genuine and written estate appraisals.

Appraisal Services urges customers not to sell their coins for scrap metal value to scrap metal buyers and local pawn shops without first getting them appraised.

This, combined with their free coin grading and verbal opinions, ensures that customers clearly understand the value of their collections.

Phone Number: (614) 832-4120
Address: 1393 Grandview Ave. Columbus, Ohio 43212

5. Buy Here Sell Here Pawn Shop

Yet another solid Pawnshop, Buy Here Sell Here Pawn Shop provides full pawnbroker services at two convenient locations in the city.

They accept all merchandise of value, with gold, silver, and precious metals at the forefront.

This, on top of their Layaway program, makes it easier to purchase what you need without having all the cash on hand.

Being a pawn shop, this is undoubtedly a perfect place to sell your gold or even leave it as collateral on a cash loan.

The shop accepts most major electronics brands besides gold and diamond jewelry. If you want to buy precious metals, it can be difficult to get a hold of what products they offer.

Since there are two stores in the city, you can easily check out both, but this is very inconvenient. Luckily, both stores have eBay shops showing what they offer.

Being a great place to sell, you have just as much of a good chance to buy precious metals from here as well.

Phone Number: (614) 914-6056 & (614) 235-6400
East Shop Address: 2344 E 5th Ave, Columbus, Ohio 43219
West Shop Address: 1257 W Broad St, Columbus, Ohio 43222

6. Big Bucks Pawn Shop

For the past six years, Big Bucks Pawn Shop has been serving customers in Central Ohio. The shop provides quick cash loans and offers customers the option to sell, pawn, buy or trade various items.

This makes this establishment a perfect place to quickly sell your precious metals. This and their guarantee to offer the best prices in Columbus make them a must-visit.

Customers who have visited the shop praise its efficient and relaxing atmosphere and appreciate the respectful and friendly employees.

Customers have received a lot of good conversations regarding their products and good money upon selling.

They recommend the shop to others and express their gratitude to the staff. With the number of positive reviews on Google and other rating-based sites, it is difficult not to recommend Big Bucks Pawn Shop.

Phone Number: (614) 864-2500
Address: 6065 East Livingston Avenue, Columbus, OH 43232

Frequently Asked Questions

Q1: How Much Do Gold Dealers Charge In Columbus, OH?

Gold dealers in Columbus will often charge you 7 to 10% over the spot price of the product you are trying to buy. This is 2 to 5% on coins and smaller products and up to 15% on larger bullion.

Q2: Are There Taxes On Purchasing Gold & Silver In Columbus, OH?

Unfortunately, people in the city of Columbus will have to pay a sales tax. This is a state-wide tax of 5.75%. It applies to all precious metal sales. With additional fees, you can see this rise to a total of 7.5%.

Q3: Can You Invest In A Gold IRA In Columbus, OH?

Investing in a gold IRA in Columbus is both possible and very easy! All you need to do is find a respectable firm that provides the service and check them out.

Gold IRA services are a perfect way to diversify your assets and expand your investment portfolio. This, however, is only possible if you have a capable firm providing you with the service. I have gone ahead and compiled various reliable gold IRA companies for your benefit!

>> CLICK HERE to read my list of the Top Precious Metals IRA Companies. <<

Additionally, you can click the link below and enjoy a FREE Gold IRA Kit. This service is provided by the company I recommend the most!


Now that you have finished reading this article, buying precious metals in Columbus should no longer be a hassle.

Check out the ones mentioned in the article above, as they are all well-established and have a great following in the community.

You should have a perfect idea of how to choose your precious metal dealer and avoid the ones that are likely to scam you.

Recent Posts